Wednesday, January 13, 2010

Hurricane Katrina and "Anarchy"

“New Orleans descends into anarchy” the headlines declared following hurricane Katrina, but they missed the real news.  The media focused on the looting, carjacking, shootings and rapes, and characterized this as anarchy, but what they were calling anarchy was actually opportunism and disorderliness.  The important news in New Orleans was not that it “descended into anarchy”, but that it “ascended” into anarchy. 

What do I mean by this?  Anarchy indeed broke out in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina, but, by definition, it was the voluntary association of individuals and groups who mobilized to offer assistance to the victims of the storm that were acting in an anarchic fashion.  The term anarchism has been perverted over time, it does not mean chaos and disorder; anarchy is simply the absence of government, anarchy is not necessarily the absence of decorum or organization.  Anarchism points to an ad hoc system of self-government, whereby free individuals organize themselves in ways that best promote the fulfillment of their ideals and the satisfaction of their needs.  This is the ideal prophesized by Jefferson

The government proved to be incompetent in the disaster relief for the victims of hurricane Katrina.  There were too many competing agendas by the local and federal agencies causing a form of paralysis.  This competition was less between the agencies, as it was the agencies in opposition to the will and needs of the victims.  The hurricane, with the failure of the dams, provided an opportunity for the government to do some social engineering and zoning modifications, with an eye towards changing the face of greater New Orleans.  This apparent agenda particularly affected the poor and disenfranchised, with the African American community the principal population affected.

Stepping in to fill the void, sometimes in opposition to the bureaucratic agenda, were many individuals and groups that felt a personal and social obligation to lend assistance to those in distress.  While the government was failing in a big government way, successes by private individuals and groups abounded. Individual citizens, church groups, and a new band of grassroots relief organizations stepped in to take up the slack.  Often rebuffing local bureaucracy and refusing government aid, most of these independent groups relied instead on small donations of money and supplies, along with a whole army of committed volunteers in the communities they serve.  Most of the entities who mobilized to help after the Katrina disaster would not, for the most part, consider themselves “anarchist”; nonetheless an accurate definition of the word, which speaks about the cooperative and voluntary association of individuals and groups as the principal mode of organizing society, puts them in this camp.

While some would surely intellectually accept that moniker, others would proudly proclaim their commitment to anarchism.  Common Ground and other organizations such as Emergency Communities, the People’s Hurricane Relief Fund, and Four Directions joined small church groups in the region to provide services where government and large aid organizations failed to meet the need. In this effort they would often ignored the authorities’ thoughtless pronouncements, finding ways to bring supplies through closed checkpoints, setting up in areas not approved by the government, breaking the rules when it made sense.  Joining in the effort to provide for the needs of the hurricane victims was a caravan of medics from the “Bay Area Radical Health Collective” as well as other activists that arrived in New Orleans to do their part, such as the Food Not Bombs groups that mobilized from all over the country to feed those displaced by Hurricane Katrina

Also on their own initiative, a multitude of celebrities stepped up to donate one million dollars each to help the Katrina effort, including The Rolling Stones, actor George Clooney, singer Celine Dion, actor Nicolas Cage, comedian Jerry Lewis, and Beyonce’s man rapper Jay-Z.   Then there was Shaquille O'Neal of the Miami Heat, with his wife Shaunie, who coordinated an effort to ship tractor-trailers full of relief supplies to Katrina's victims.  

Angelina Jolie upset at what she saw was not happening in New Orleans wrote to Congress and the White House asking for more disaster relief.  John Travolta, flew to Baton Rouge with his wife Kelly Preston, carrying food supplies and vaccines.  Singer Macy Gray visited a camp in Houston, Texas and handed out clothing and toiletries.  Oprah Winfrey abandoned her summer vacation to visit those affected by Hurricane Katrina.

There was also a legion of ordinary citizens like Gary Maclaughlin who bought a used school bus and filled it with diapers and other supplies and drove it to New Orleans, then picked up a number of evacuees from the airport and drove them to a rescue shelter in Louisiana.  

There was David Perez, chairman of Surge Global Energy, who decided to spend a quarter million dollars to charter a plane and purchase a planeload of relief supplies. Later, he evacuated 82 hurricane victims and flew them to San Diego where arrangements were being made to help them. Then a Fort Lauderdale attorney Herb Cohen assembled a team of four medical professionals from Orlando. The group traveled to Houston on a jet paid for by the Aero Toy Store to provide medical assistance to evacuees.

A legion of groups also spontaneously assembled in New Orleans’s to give aid, like the coworkers at Smith & Associates in Tampa, Florida, who collected $20,000 worth of supplies for Katrina's victims. They filled two trucks with diapers, baby food and formula.  A group of people from the small town of Union, South Carolina, drove to Atlanta to pick up five families left homeless by the hurricane, giving them a place to live, along with groceries and utilities for at least two months.  Employees of the Columbus, Georgia, Courtyard by Marriott pooled their room vouchers, which they earned as bonuses, to give an evacuated family a hotel room for about to weeks; other employees took up collections to buy shoes for the children of evacuees.

Church congregations helping hurricane victims are to numerous to mention, but here are a few. Two of the churches in Ashley County, Arkansas (Promise Land Missionary Baptist Church and Calvary Baptist Church) offered to house a total of 75 people.  St. Patrick's church in nearby Phoenix City, Alabama, served hurricane evacuees a Thanksgiving-style dinner for Labor Day. Several truckloads of tents, sleeping bags, bottles of drinking water, and five-gallon gas containers for Katrina's victims were sent to the Gulf Coast from the Latter Day Saints.

And, not to be left out was the nation's children, from preschoolers to teens, who found enterprising ways to raise funds for Katrina's victims.  Six-year-old Angelo Ward and his four siblings set up a lemonade stand in front of an supermarket and collected $735 in one weekend.  Ten-year-old Melissa McLean of Hollywood, Florida, raised more than $700 in two days selling lemonade at a street corner in her neighborhood. Six-year-old Thomas Caruso of Paramus, New Jersey, watched the news as a Katrina victim holding her baby cried for help. He decided to give the $200 he had saved for a new Nintendo game to the hurricane victims.  Ten pre-teens from Howard, Wisconsin, sold curbside Kool-Aid, freeze pops, and cookies and raised $60 for the Red Cross.

With the present disaster in Haiti, I revisited the media’s love affair with the term anarchy as a means of titillation in addressing that disaster.  The best the press could come up with were instances of sporadic violence and looting, which they were quick to call anarchy.   As for sporadic violence, I live in a city with a cop on just about every other corner and we experience sporadic violence regularly.

As for the so called looting, it was generally in the nature of salvaging abandoned property of owners who were either missing or dead, very little of the looting was of a criminal nature (this even with the prisons destroyed in the quake allowing three thousand inmates to escape).  The true anarchy in Haiti was exhibited by the grace and stoicism shown by the Haitian people, who, finding no immediate aid from the international community, used hammers and bare hands to rescue the trapped and to administer aid to the injured.

The Haitian people shared what little they had and bolstered each others spirits with song and dance; they coped with the situation the best they could in a country that was economically devastated before this natural disaster. 

Given the spontaneity and success of these grassroots mobilizations in both Katrina and now Haiti, I would say that anarchy is the natural state of society.  It is clear by now that government creates its own agenda over time and this agenda is often in conflict with society needs. At those times it is our obligation as members of society to step in and take back the reigns of sovereignty.  I predict that Katrina marks the beginning of a revolution of conscience that will continue to escalate as society deals with the failures of government. 


Copyright 2009 - 2011

Tuesday, January 12, 2010

Intelligent Design from an Inventor's POV

Here’s my take on the whole evolution vs. creationism debate.  Creationists insist that there is an “intelligent designer” behind all living things; by this they mean a supreme being that creates everything “whole cloth” almost instantly as a celestial inventor, this despite the growing evidence on the nature of evolution. 

Looking at the history of inventing, I can’t find a single invention that was created whole cloth from the mind of the inventor without reference to something that came before it.  There is an evolutionary process at work in the design of all practical artifacts produced by man throughout history. In each case, the most useful objects and processes available are drawn upon for inspiration in the development of the most functional new version of an idea.   

This seems to be how nature works as well, creation is an evolutionary progression.  This does not rule out some underlying or innate intelligence at work in the process.  An innate intelligence does not portent a supreme being; it may simply point to a lack of understanding of the nature of intelligence. Who knows, intelligence may be a vestige of “god”, but only through the continual search for truth will we approach illumination on that matter.

Inventors apply intelligence to solving problems, but as I look around at “creation” I find it difficult to accept on the face of it the notion there is an intelligent designer at work in the formation of humans.  As an inventor I must point out that, as it concerns the development of human beings, this alleged intelligent designer was less than generous in the attributes assigned to the “pinnacle of all creation.” 

If I were an almighty inventor and had the benefit of all of my previous works, there are a few innovations that I’d be remiss not to include in my greatest creation.  For one, there is the regeneration of lost or damaged limbs.  If I endowed a lowly newt and other creatures with this potential, it would be a shame not to provide the same advantage to my most ambitious creation.  Regeneration of limbs in newts occurs first by de-differentiation of adult cells into cells similar to embryonic cells and then development of these cells into new tissue.  It’s interesting to me, that the “intelligent creator” left this task to its “creation,” through stem cell research, to use its intelligence to do what the creator apparently ignored. 

Then there is the question of flight.  Here is another attribute that was left up to the “creation” to realize, building on trial and error to achieve flight, applying intelligence over the ages to discover the means.  I imagine that more than a few early humans lost their lives in an attempt to fly.  First by simply jumping off ledges and flapping their arms, or even wearing feathers in imitation of birds; over time observations and refinements provided insights into the mechanism of flight until a solution was finally achieved. So it turns out, even human flight was evolutionary.

With the inevitability of death, mortality is especially hard to face when we understand there is a possibility of immortality.  Therefore, I would also endow my ultimate creation with the potential for immortality as with the Hydra, a genus of simple fresh-water animals whose cells continually divide allowing defects and toxins to be "diluted-away"; it is thought that hydras do not undergo aging.  Then there is Turritopsis nutricula a species of jellyfish that uses Tran differentiation to become younger after sexual reproduction; this cycle can repeat indefinitely, rendering it potentially immortal.  I can’t think of a better justification for having sex.

Of course, if we were made in the creator’s image, one would expect that we would be endowed with the attribute of immortality.  Some would argue the “creator” felt the ability to be immortal would make humans to much like gods, or that immortality should be reserved for those obedient servants for the “afterlife” as a gift for their faithfulness, but these apologies do not reflect well on a caring and loving god. 

Looking beyond the innovations the creator neglected to include in the pinnacle of creation, there are also the seemingly unforeseen consequences of some of the final design choices left to chance.  For instance, a fertilized egg in a woman can implant itself in many different places in the reproductive system before it reaches the uterus causing an ectopic pregnancy.  Prior to modern surgery, ectopic pregnancy caused the deaths of both mother and baby.  Even today, in almost all cases, the pregnancy must be aborted to save the life of the mother.  Since a cavity exists between the ovary and the fallopian tube one could argue this is a sign of a flawed design in the reproductive system. 

Also, the birth canal in females passes through the pelvis, if the baby’s head is significantly larger than the pelvic opening the baby cannot be born naturally.  Before the development of the C-section, this could lead to the death of the mother, the baby or both; an omnificent god would surely have caught these flaws and corrected them immediately.

Further, there is a glaring defect in the human male whose testes develop early within the abdomen; later during development they migrate through the abdominal wall into the scrotum. This causes weak points in the abdominal wall where hernias can form; prior to current surgical techniques complications from hernias usually resulted in death.  


For me, these apparent blunders suggest an evolutionary process at work, not an omniscient intelligent designer creating the world whole cloth.  I would suggest its not intelligent design; it’s intelligence in the design.  I think someday we may discover that what we call intelligence may be an agent in evolution.  This treatise is not a repudiation of the existence of god per se; it only calls into question the method of “creation.”  

Friday, January 8, 2010

Democratizing Capital

“Why are the rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer?” This is a perennial and persistent question on economics. The answer, simply put, is because ownership of productive capital is skewed towards the very wealthy. The top 1% of households have 38.3% of all privately held stock, 60.6% of financial securities, and 62.4% of business assets, while the richest 10 percent of families own about 85 percent of all outstanding stocks, about 85 percent of all financial securities and 90 percent of all business assets. The multinational corporations controlled by this concentration of capital control the world’s Capitals. By the use of heavy lobbying, along with other efforts like political contributions, government policies are implemented that favor the corporations over the citizens. By this means, a cabal of private interest represented largely by the top 1% maintains dominance and influence over the economies of the earth, often having more power than governments.

Capitalism is contrived to reward productive capital, while it usurps the fruits of human capital with economic force; the resultant imbalance and concentration of capital is driving a modern feudalism. The vast majority of the population is enslaved by capital’s demands; we are indentured servants by design and choice (though it’s more of a Hobson’s choice). For the most part we in the 99% are vested in capitalism through debt, as a result we posses very little power in economic decision making. Servicing our personal debt erodes our economic capital; consequently our options and potential for change are heavily restricted.

Given the facts concerning the concentration of capital, it is clear the recent bailout of Wall Street was about bailing out the wealthy; this at the expense of the working poor and middleclass who make up the vast majority of the 99%. The good news is the recent failure of the capital market has handed us a great opportunity to re-imagine and re-invent our economic system in a way that will serve all society and not just transfer money to the wealthy 1%. It is not society’s duty to serve the economy of the wealthy; the economy should be structured to serve society.

With the near collapse of the capital market we have the lucky opportunity to reinvent an economic system that is based on innovation and collaboration that can provide for both our physical and metaphysical needs, while leading toward individual fulfillment.  We must pursue a grassroots effort to divert economic resources away from those few who are engaged in crony capitalism perpetuating a paradigm that is unsustainable and to reroute those resources towards a free-enterprise system that empowers all individuals and families through direct and effective ownership of the means of production.  

There is a great amount of underutilized human capital available that can be engaged productively.  We possess in abundance all of the essential elements of economic growth, time, energy, needs and skills which makes up our human capital.  Our human capital also comprises our healthy physical capacity to produce for the future, in concert with our acquired knowledge, skills and experience.  The challenge ahead is to take our human capital and put it to work in our communities to operate as a wealth generator to satisfy our personal and societal needs, while at the same time accumulating productive capital towards a sustainable economy.  

Let’s be real, many of the jobs lost in the present depression will never come back, any recovery must come from the growth of new enterprises.  Human capital provides the engine that propels the economy; this engine can be retooled to run efficiently on alternative economic energy in the same way our cars must be retooled to run on alternative energy.  It is in our self interest to band together to cooperate, collaborate and engage in what might be considered altruistic activities to attain economic rewards. 

Our communities need to be creative in finding alternative solutions for nurturing healthier homegrown local economies, providing for bottom up growth.  There are numerous potential strategies, some of them well proven, that can be applied to produce local wealth such as cooperatives, employee owned companies, companies offering ESOPs (Employee Stock Ownership Plans), complementary currencies, community land trusts, local barter-clubs, time banking, people-to-people lending and micro-lending to name just a few. 

The use of local complementary currencies enables communities to more fully employ its available productive resources; particularly the residual unemployed labor from the present depression.  Through associations of small local banks and/or credit unions, along with businesses, we can provide a capital support network to facilitate emerging economic activities.  Further, a local complementary currency will circulate more consistently within the community than the national currency, having a greater multiplier effect on the local economy.  Local currency usage encourages the trade of available goods and services that are produced locally.

I call upon the nouveau riche to take an initiative in this endeavor, by taking a leadership role in a grass roots effort to bestow the benefits of “capitalism” to the population in general by which society can evolve into a more vibrant and collaborative body, making productive capital broadly owned so as to have the effect of vesting ownership and profit potential in society at large.  We can begin by envisioning local solutions to local problems; solutions managed by local communities empowering the thousand points of light and rewarding individual initiatives to solve problems and produce results.

There is an enormous array of experimental and proven strategies for community development that can be employed to reinvent and reinvigorate the local economy, as well as to help build productive capital for expanding local opportunities.  The list below delineates some of the strategies and democratic capital structures being offered in the virtual marketplace, this list provides an idea of the breath of the movement towards strengthening our local economies at the grass roots level.  Take some time to explore these economic options by researching them on the internet, become familiar with what’s out there and share it with those close to you. 

As you feel comfortable with your understanding of the value of one or more of these initiatives for your life and community, begin implementing them with your neighbors.  I suggest each one of us identify the circle or circles of affinity that inform and nurture our lives and look to these alliances as a nexus for implementing change towards democratizing capitalism. 


Many will find their church offers a communion of like minded cohorts that will provide the support of service for reconstructing the community at large.   Other’s may turn to the virtual community of social networking as an extension of their local community, to strategize and share what works and does not work as an immediate and vital link to an expanding consciousness leading to an economic self-sufficiency revolution.  

Ø Worker Co-Operatives
Ø Consumer/Retail Co-Operatives
Ø Housing Co-Operatives
Ø Agricultural Co-Operatives
Ø Health Care Co-Operatives
Ø Employee-Owned Business
Ø Development Trusts
Ø Community Foundations
Ø Social Firms
Ø Intermediate Labor Market Projects
Ø Credit Unions
Ø Community Loan Funds
Ø Friendly Societies
Ø Mutual Insurers
Ø Building Societies
Ø Charitable Trading Arms
Ø Let Schemes - Local Exchange Trading Systems
Ø Community Currency
Ø Community Sponsored Agricultural
Ø Consumer Stock Ownership Plans (CSOP); stock ownership plans for utility users and regular customers of enterprises.
Ø Community Investment Corporation (CIC) sharing profits from local land planning and development including structural developments such as highways, railways, bridges, utility companies, harbors, tunnels, etc
Ø Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP), which has a proven track record in the United States with 1,500 corporations 100% employee-owned.
Ø The Homestead Act

You can find links to websites devoted to these community actions at my website www.vera-city.net, including a proposal for a hybrid global digital complementary currency called the Vera.

Copyright © 2009 - 2012

Monday, December 14, 2009

The Seeds of My Dissent are Sowed!

I am created as an atheist and anarchist; it’s “god’s” will and my destiny.   I was fashioned in an existential crucible shaped by a society that prefers myth and superstition above truth and reason.

From my youth, I was indoctrinated with a vision of a socio-political and religious belief system that painted America as utopian.  Growing up, I was saturated by the media with the accepted affirmation on “truth, justice and the American way”, but my personal experience of reality did not jive with the belief system I was blithely asked to embrace.  This utopian vision, as defined by my church and the state, proved to be dystopian.  I struggled with the dichotomy between what I was taught to believe and what my experiences were telling me.   Where was I to find “truth”?

My story begins very early in my youth, when a soul wrenching incident occurred to me that shook the foundation of my entire belief system.  My father turned up dead while in the custody of the corrupt police in a suburb of Chicago, within mafia territory.  The police told our family one story; the local newspaper printed a conflicting story, and worst of all our parish priest, while speaking to the children, violated one of the ten commandments by lying about my father’s death (a big deal for a young initiate). 

None of the stories conformed to each other and all were at odds with the facts; the evidence pointed to the murder of my father at the hands of the police who claimed it was a suicide.  The truth was covered up by the police, along with the local paper and the mortuary where my father was interred.  When my uncles started asking the police for some answers to the inconsistencies in the story about their brother’s death, they where rounded up by the police and escorted, not just out of the city or county, but all the way to the Illinois/Kentucky state line. With continuing threats to my family, we where compelled to move out of town; the truth never came out. 

Thus, at the age of ten the very foundation of my belief system was disturbed before it had a chance to fully form.  Following the murder of my father I was faced with a mystery where the truth was obfuscated and difficult to discover. There was a tacit agreement between church and state to construct a truth that served their wishes, leaving me confused and without mooring. 

Following that experience, I found myself alone and adrift in a sea of confusion, grabbling with pressing existential questions about the meaning of life and the nature of truth.  I found myself set on a lonesome journey, adrift in a sea of confusion and apprehension, seeking existential truth.  I was left with no answers, only questions. 

As I pursued those questions the questions only proliferated.  I found myself caught in a maelstrom of contradictions and ambiguity. Would I ever be able to reconcile what I was taught to believe with what my experience was actually showing me? 

As I grew older, more incidents with the church and its insufficient answers further widened the chasm that originated with the earlier fracture of my faith.  The straw that broke the camels back was when I was told by a nun that my questions on the existence and nature of god could only be answered by god when I went to heaven; I lost interest in the teachings of the church.  

Adding to this incident is a whole series of unsatisfactory experiences with the church amounting to psychological torture, I found myself on a life long quest for truth or at least something in which I could have faith.  Not just something to believe in, not “blind faith”, but something that stood up to reason. 

Over time, I’ve come to understand there are no definitive answers defining an absolute truth, there is only the journey and the residual experiences that leave a sense of the truth, a common sense that embraces the riches of beliefs systems, while ultimately rejecting them all.  It seems truth is found in the seams!

A further assault on my faltering belief system occurred while pursuing the “American Dream” as a young adult.  Unlawful actions taken by government officials “under the color of law” obliterated my already sagging belief in government and the notion of the “rule of law”. 

I was engaged in a perfectly ordinary real estate partnership with two of my brothers to purchase distressed properties and save them from decay, but it turned out the county government had a hidden agenda on one of our properties.  In the process of pursuing their agenda the government officials engaged in activities that if done by the ordinary citizen would be criminal.  In its attempt to take property held by our family partnership, the state and local government violated our constitutional rights.  A protracted lawsuit against the government followed that lasted over a half a decade.    

This assault on my liberty and happiness was specious and insidious; the anger inside me from this egregious assault was so great as to bring me close to the line that separates anger at the few to condemnation of the whole; for the first time in my life I understood terrorist.  I felt rage and despair, but in my favor, I’ve always had hope.  But how deep is this reservoir of hope?  Could the well run dry?  I have an enduring sense of humor I inherited from my mother and this has served me will; I can laugh even as I cry.

As a result of these various transgressions by both church and state, I’ve completely lost the cozy feeling that once wrapped me in a blanket of security and comfort early in my youth.  There is no longer a warm fuzzy feeling inside me when I view symbols of the church or state.  My visceral reaction is disdain; I am compelled by distrust, to shun both authorities.  To the extent society as a whole has embraced the myths perpetrated by these institutions my trepidation is further confirmed. 

When the myth and the truth are in conflict, faith cannot survive without degenerating to blind faith.   Faith is based on trust, if you can no longer trust what is being offered as the truth then you are delusional if you continue to have faith.  Over the years, I have learned to keep my own council and find comfort in limbo.



Copyright © 2010 – 2012

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

"How Rich is too Rich"

The question “How rich, is too rich?” was posited by Donald Trump in an interview with a nationally syndicated host, when asked if he wasn’t already rich enough.  In a taunting manner Mr. Trump repeated this question over and over again, throwing out figures like “one million”, “ten million”, come on tell me, a hundred million, finally intimidating the interviewer into an uncomfortable chuckle; I too was uncomfortable watching him.  My first thought was, Mr. Trump, if you feel the need to defend your wealth, you’re already too rich. 

Trump’s question raised a challenge within me; his sarcastic attitude spurred me on to find a satisfactory answer to his forced query.  To focus simply on the dollar amount, as Trump did, is inadequate to qualify an answer to this question, we must look for a more fundamental principle to flesh out a universal answer to this enigma. 

To discover a principal that satisfies this question, I focused on folks whose wealth is publicly evident and I asked if each were too rich.  I’ve already proffered the notion, that if a person is concerned about the size of their wealth their values are mislaid and they’re already to rich; if this type of wealth is the measure of their self worth their personal worth is inflated; in other words, they’re too big for their britches.  When asked a similar question on the notion of distribution of wealth, I’ve heard numerous people who were financially wealthy retort “Why should I be compelled to give away any of my money?  I’ve earned it by myself and I should be able to keep it all.” 

This claim would be fine if they earned their wealth in a vacuum without the participation of anyone else, but we don’t operate in a vacuum, we operate in a society.  In society, especially one that has developed an overarching state with layers of bureaucracy and regulations, citizens give up a measure of their personal sovereignty to create the state and provide the environment were wealth is not just produced, but accumulated.  Without this broad sacrifice of sovereignty by society at large, it would be impossible for anyone to legitimately accumulate vast wealth in relative safety.  In addition, there is a shared largess of ideas, methods and tools that have been accumulated by society over the ages that has contributed to the common wealth of society; this also represents an advantage not individually earned. 

When you contrast this selfish world view held by many with people like Oprah, Magic Johnson, the Newman’s, Jimmy Carter, the Gates and Warren Buffett, along with countless other people who give freely of their time and money we discover a different metrics for determining wealth.  People of this ilk can never be two rich, they will always give according to how blessed they feel about their wealth. 

Giving by the wealthy is not some bleeding heart liberal nonsense; it should be considered an obligation by those who have benefited from societies largess; it should also be regarded as a responsible business strategy.  I’m sure Oprah as a businessperson and philanthropist can attest that the more she gives the greater her popularity; her shows ratings are improved enhancing her wealth, both physical and metaphysical.  Sharing one’s wealth abundantly is synergistic releasing an actualizing power that is infectious and motivates others to contribute their wealth; wealth is actually amplified. Stinginess and amassing wealth is a zero sum game; it shifts the financial wealth to the wealthy and leaves the poor poorer. 

Giving doesn’t need to be a strictly charitable effort to be effective.  There are financial opportunities with charitable attributes which can bestow similar benefits as a charity, while earning a pecuniary benefit.  One idea, known as peer to peer funding, provides low cost financing to micro businesses.  Another strategy is to become part of an investment group in your community and invest in innovative local small businesses that fall outside the credit system.  Join together with others in your church, mosque or synagogue to refinance individual members of the congregation’s credit card debt, with a personal loan in aggregation with others in order to spread the risk, which will provide an economic opportunity to the loan pool, while allowing the recipient to put the savings from the debt reduction towards accumulating productive capital.  Be creative, express your wealth; look around your community to find a need and fill it!

Copyright 2009 - 2011


Thursday, December 3, 2009

Art & Obscenity

With the release of Annie Liebowitz’s photo of Miley Cyrus in the Vanity Fair Magazine, some in the news media reported that it was risqué or obscene, even reporting that Miley was half nude. I was dismayed by how many editorials were fixated on sex and nudity, which was not universally apparent in the photos. If there were any obscene connotations in the photo it is in the mind of the beholder; in my mind there is nothing implicitly or explicitly sexual in the photo.

There were incredible statements about how the photo was “exploitative of the innocent”, that it was “suggestive”, “child pornography” and that the magazine was “selling sex”. There was one particularly over-the-top comment made by an editor of Entertainment Weekly who remarked "…if Miley Cyrus is going to go around naked but for fabric draped over her, she's just begging us to imagine what her firm, young breasts look like, her smooth, tan skin, her tight, virgin...well, you get the idea. And I think that's shameful." WHAT? WHAT?? WHAT IS THIS GUY TALKING ABOUT?

There is nothing inherent in Annie’s photo of Miley that is shameful. What’s shameful is the values ascribed to this photo by those who desire to view it in a strictly prurient manner. These people expressing these thoughts need to understand that obscenity is generated in their own minds. The word obscene comes from the Greeks who did not like to show murder explicitly in their dramas, they chose to do it off-scene and left it to the imagination of the audience. I wasn’t invited by the photo to imagine the thoughts expressed by the editor and others like him; when I view this photo I see it clearly as a work of art. I am not titillated by it, indeed I feel a sense of melancholy when I view it; to me it’s an enigmatic vision like that of the Mona Lisa.

To demonstrate my perception of the photo as a kind of homage to the Mona Lisa, I down loaded and I compared it to the Miley Cyrus photo; one cannot help but be amazed at its similarity. Annie’s photo of Miley possesses many of the artistic qualities of Leonardo da Vinci’s painting. Take a moment compare the two, look at the mouth, the eyes, and the crossed hands, even the highlights on the skin. Then look at the folds of the clothing, the variegated background, as well as the overall near monochromatic color of the respective pictures. I would say that Annie’s photo of Miley should be considered a 21st Century Mona Lisa.



Those who rage vociferously against “obscenity” appear to observe the world through a perverted mind and wish to prescribe it to others, they perceive obscenity everywhere. The same type of perverted thinking has characterized many other pieces of art throughout the ages as obscene, including such treasures as the Venus de Milo, Botticelli's Birth of Venus and Michelangelo's David. In fact when several clerics viewed Michelangelo's work in the Sistine Chapel for the first time, they accused him of obscenity and consequently covered his nudes.

Recently, officials in Bartholomew County Indiana notified a business that sells copies of classical art that they must be move certain statues out of view from the window, as these classic art pieces would be considered obscene under state law. The statues included copies of Michelangelo's David and the Venus de Milo. Also, a parent in Shelton Connecticut recently asked the school to change his daughter's bus route, so she could avoid seeing a 15-foot high replica of Michelangelo's ''David'' at an office park; the bus route was moved.
Those who have obscene thoughts in their heads when viewing Liebowitz’s photo of Miley, or any other piece of art for that matter, need to take responsibility for their own obscene thoughts, they need to own them and not ascribe them to the population at large. I would suggest they should commence a study of art from a rational unpolluted mindset and develop new ways of viewing the world around them. A world were art is allowed to flourish is a richer and more caring world.

Just for fun I’ve swapped the faces of Miley and Mona. What do you think? Whatever it is, own it!



Copyright © 2009 - 2011